A Mental Issue

This post from Bitter got me to thinking about a related issue concerning firearms.  I’m pondering the ramifications of giving access to a firearm during a training session to a person who has been prescribed antidepressants.  Texas law is certainly not clear (at least to me) on this issue, but more importantly, I want to be as careful as possible.  In fact, Texas law only addresses this issue in relation to the CHL statutes in a section on whether “a person is incapable of exercising sound judgment with respect to the proper use and storage of a handgun” (Section 411.172, Subsection d of the Texas Government Code).  Further, it never addresses the issue of depression or treatment for depression.  Instead, it includes this catch-all phrase (Section 411.172(d)(1)):

has been diagnosed by a licensed physician as suffering from a psychiatric disorder or condition that causes or is likely to cause substantial impairment in judgment, mood, perception, impulse control, or intellectual ability;

This one will definitely require more thought.  On one side, you don’t want to give access to a gun to someone who could be suicidal.  At the same time, you also don’t want to deny knowledge of gun handling to someone who is actually interested (either for safety or self-protection reasons).

Update:  Another thought occurred to me after I wrote this.  I wonder if any gun owners have avoided getting help for depression for fear of losing their CHLs (or even their guns).

3 Comments

  1. Bitter Bitch says:

    I actually had to deny a friend the right to go to the range once because I knew that she wasn’t legally allowed to handle a firearm due to her mental health history.  It sucked because she’s got her life in control now and she really wanted to learn how to use a firearm.

  2. That’s definitely a tough situation.  Does your state have a provision for allowing people to handle guns again after they get their condition under control?  In re-reading the Texas statutes yesterday, I found that a person could get regain eligibility for a CHL if they could get a doctor to certify that the condition is in remission (or no longer exists).  Interestingly, as I noted earlier, Texas law doesn’t seem to address the issue of mental illness with regards to everyday gun posession, just in regards to CHLs.

  3. shell says:

    It hadn’t even occured to me that my mental health might be an issue.  I’ll have to go research Virginia law before I buy my first gun.  But as a general observation, someone who is taking antidepressants is probably safer than a depressed person who’s not being treated.